Renaissance Square Regrets?

We should talk about Renaissance Square.

I join you in wishing we never, ever have to talk about the failed project again, but this week’s events make it necessary.

Renaissance Square would have combined a performing arts center, bus station and Monroe Community College campus on the northwest corner of Main and Clinton. A bunch of eyesore buildings would have been knocked down. The $230 million project was funded with the exception of a performing arts center.

The project was led by Republican Maggie Brooks. Democrats (and the public) never warmed up to it. When then-Mayor Robert Duffy finally became engaged with the details – after $24 million and years of planning – he had major reservations. Bickering over performing arts center funding and the size of the bus terminal ended up dooming the project.

Did I mention Renaissance Square was funded??? The bus company told the city if money for the theater never materialized, the city would get that parcel back for development. A clean shovel-ready site at Main and Clinton. (I’ve always believed a theater could be funded if the mayor and county executive truly championed it.)

But City Hall effectively killed Renaissance Square. Brooks could have continued negotiations with the city, but she’d had enough. She shares some blame for walking away, but it’s not like Duffy went running after her to salvage anything.  The whole thing left Senator Chuck Schumer, who fought for project funding, truly baffled.

Fast forward two years. The bus terminal will be breaking ground this spring in the same Renaissance Square location with essentially the same design.  MCC is saying “good riddance” to Main Street, putting in jeopardy plans to develop the Sibley Building. A performing arts center hasn’t raised any funds and would be more expensive to build at the preferred Midtown site. The eyesore block at Main and Clinton still stands, with no development proposals ostensibly in the works.

Killing Renaissance Square had major consequences. The biggest, we now see, is MCC’s departure from the heart of downtown. Unless developers come out of the woodwork to revitalize Main Street, the death of that project still looms large.


2 responses to “Renaissance Square Regrets?

  1. It died of its own shortcomings. A city is built for pedestrians, just as the suburbs are built for cars. City streets require abundant entry and exits to stores, businesses, retailers, and residences. The purpose of transportation is to extend the range of the pedestrian. Big Box projects like Ren Sq. are misguided attempts to apply suburban mall solutions to urban needs. These projects end up with large dead spaces like South Avenue from Main St. to the Inner Loop. The historic buildings along the north block of Main are structurally sound and can be adapted to new uses while restoring and retaining their late 19th and early 20th century facades. As far as the Midtown site, take a look at Gateway Center in downtown Salt Lake City or Country Club/Alameda Plaza in downtown Kansas City. Adaptations of these are what will make the center of Rochester vibrant once again. Big Boxes with limited access and things like gambling casinos are not the answer.

  2. No No No! This article is bad! Renaissance Square would have been an epic failure! The bus station was the major issue because many of the people who ride the buses are poor and criminals. Having sketchy people hanging out around main street would ruin midtown. Also those buildings are historic and you cant replace that history. History is one of the only things downtown rochester has left! Who wants to shop and spend money and go to school around poor people?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s